The brand, graded

The Butternut Co.

3 products on the index · average grade D (48/100) · 0 score A–B, 1 score D–F

Davg 48
best of the lineup
CProtein Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butter (Creamy)53/100
worst of the lineup
DChocolate Peanut Butter (Creamy)39/100
what The Butternut Co. shouts
“32g protein per serving”“32g protein”“chocolatey breakfast treat”
what the math says

Across the lineup the brand averages grade D. More snack than supplement. 1 of 3 land in D–F territory once you score usable protein, value and hidden sugar, not the headline gram count.

Every The Butternut Co. product, best to worst

1CProtein Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butter (Creamy)Nuts & spreads · 36 g/100 g · ₹64/20 g usable532CNatural Peanut Butter (Unsweetened, Crunchy)Nuts & spreads · 32 g/100 g · ₹66/20 g usable523DChocolate Peanut Butter (Creamy)Nuts & spreads · 20 g/100 g · ₹109/20 g usable39
Compare every brand on the index →How much protein do you need?

Graded by math, not brands. Macros are label/brand-listed (June 2026); not medical advice.